Skip to content

Why Our First Instinct Is to Add More—Even When Taking Something Away Works Better

In Simple Terms

When we try to improve something, we often think about what to add and forget to ask what we could remove. Studies show that people may overlook simple solutions that involve taking something away, even when those solutions are cheaper or easier. A quick reminder to consider removal can help—but adding is sometimes the right choice, too.

A Design Insight Becomes a Research Question

Researchers Gabriel Adams, Benjamin Converse, Andrew Hales, and Leidy Klotz of the University of Virginia published a study in Nature in 2021. Klotz, an engineer, had noticed that design improvements based on removing elements seemed less common than one might expect. Working with Adams, a social psychologist, the team turned that observation into a direct question: Do people really tend to overlook removal when asked to make something better?

The researchers looked beyond laboratory puzzles. They analyzed suggestions submitted to a new university president, who had asked for ideas to help the institution serve its students and community better. Just 11 percent of the suggestions called for eliminating an existing rule, practice, or program; the rest proposed additions. That figure alone cannot explain why people made those choices, but it offers a real-world example of how a request for improvement can prompt new ideas more readily than a review of what is already in place.

The team then tested the idea in eight studies involving more than 1,100 people. The tasks included geometric puzzles, designing a miniature golf course, and building with LEGO bricks. By using different kinds of tasks, the researchers could see whether the tendency to add appeared across a range of problems, rather than in just one particular puzzle.

One LEGO Brick Can Separate a Simple Fix from a Costly One

In one LEGO task, a small figurine sat beneath a roof supported at one corner by a single brick. Participants were asked to change the structure so it could hold a real building brick on top without collapsing onto the figurine. Each participant had a $1 budget for the change, while each additional LEGO brick cost 10 cents.

There was a solution that required no purchase: remove the lone support so the roof could rest directly on the base. Yet that option did not occur to everyone automatically. When the instructions mentioned only the cost of adding bricks, 41 percent of participants chose to remove the support. When the instructions also pointed out that removing it was free, that share rose to 61 percent.

The difference between those figures tells us two things. First, a brief reminder that something could be removed changed the choices of a substantial number of participants. Second, removal had been possible from the start, but simply having that option available was not enough to ensure that everyone considered it. In this task, participants did not need to invent a new material or pay for one. They just needed to notice that an existing brick was getting in the way of a simpler arrangement.

A similar pattern appeared in another task involving colored squares on a grid. Participants had to make a shape symmetrical. They could do so by adding squares to the less-filled side or removing some from the fuller side. Many chose to fill the gap rather than reduce the excess, even though removal could complete the task more efficiently. These examples suggest that the bias is not just about money: adding may simply be the option that comes to mind first.

Why Doesn’t Removal Occur to Us?

According to the research team, people do not necessarily consider removal-based solutions and then reject them after weighing the alternatives. The problem can come earlier: ideas for additions arise more easily, while spotting what could be taken away requires extra mental effort. When someone starts looking for a way to improve something, they may implicitly interpret the task as an invitation to introduce something new.

Other experiments explored this explanation from several angles. Participants were more likely to come up with removal-based ideas when they were prompted to think about taking something away, given more time, or allowed to practice this kind of solution. Rushing or being distracted made those ideas less common. The tendency, then, does not seem to be a fixed judgment that cannot be changed. How a task is framed and how much time people have can affect which options they notice.

Another possibility appeared in a commentary accompanying the study in Nature, written by consumer psychologist Tom Meyvis of New York University and a colleague. Some people may believe that proposing a new addition will earn them more appreciation than suggesting that something already in place should be removed. If so, their choices may not be driven by ease of thought alone. Expectations about how others will judge an idea could also encourage people to add.

But this possibility should not be treated as a finding established by the experiments themselves. The main study showed that people often overlook solutions involving removal, and that a reminder makes them more likely to notice those options. The role of social rewards—or of concerns about seeming like someone who is cutting services—remains a plausible explanation that needs to be tested separately.

From Lab Puzzles to an Overloaded Calendar

The 2021 experiments did not directly test whether removing tasks makes people more successful at work or in their personal lives. It is important, therefore, to distinguish what the study demonstrated from what it might suggest about other decisions. The puzzle findings can prompt us to think about how we manage our commitments, but they do not prove that canceling a particular task or habit will improve everyone’s life.

Still, the idea connects with research on how people estimate their time. In 2005, Gal Zauberman of the University of North Carolina and John Lynch of Duke University published a study in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. They found that people tend to expect more free time in the future than they have in the present, and that this optimism about time is stronger than their optimism about money. As a result, someone may agree today to future commitments they would turn down if asked to take them on right now. When those commitments arrive, they may find themselves just as busy as before. The researchers also noted that people are continually surprised by how busy they are on any given day.

This finding helps explain how additions can pile up over time. A new appointment seems manageable because it is far off; another project seems easy to handle because it has not started yet. Then they all come together in an overloaded schedule. That does not mean every commitment should be canceled. But our predictions about future free time may be more optimistic than reality, so it can be useful to revisit what we have already agreed to rather than assume that our schedules will somehow make room.

A related, though distinct, line of research was published in PNAS in 2009 by Eyal Ophir, Clifford Nass, and Anthony Wagner of Stanford University. The study compared people who regularly used multiple media sources at the same time with people who did so less often. The first group was more easily distracted by irrelevant information and performed worse on a test of switching between tasks. Later studies produced mixed results, so the issue should not be considered settled. The example is a limited reminder that taking in more things at once does not necessarily help us get more done.

Taken together, these strands of research do not mean that having fewer goals is always better or that additions are mistakes. The point is that adding can become the default response: if we want to make progress, we add a goal; if a problem comes up, we add a rule; if work gets crowded, we add a tool or a meeting. Those steps can make things more complicated, while we fail to seriously consider whether easing or reducing what is already there might work better.

How to Make Removal an Option

One striking practical finding is that the bias was not impossible to change. In the LEGO task, explaining that removing bricks cost nothing shifted the choice from 41 to 61 percent. That does not prove the same reminder will solve problems in organizations or everyday life, but it suggests that the way we phrase a question can broaden our thinking. Instead of asking only, What should I add?, we can ask a second question alongside it: What do I no longer need?

This idea can be applied to a work schedule without assuming that every meeting is useless. Before adding another meeting, we can review the existing ones and ask whether any serve the same purpose. Before adopting an additional procedure, we can identify the problem it is meant to address, then consider whether an older procedure could be ended or simplified. When managing personal tasks, regularly reviewing recurring commitments can help distinguish what provides real value from what remains on the calendar simply because no one has decided to stop doing it.

It also helps to make sure requests for ideas are not limited to additions. Teams, for example, could ask each person for two suggestions: one thing to start doing and one thing to stop or reduce. This approach does not automatically make the second option better, but it gives that option a fair chance to emerge. Setting aside a few quiet minutes for review may also be more useful than making a decision under time pressure, since the experiments found that rushing and distraction reduce the likelihood of discovering removal-based solutions.

At the same time, removal should be evaluated carefully. Eliminating a rule could remove an important safeguard, and cutting a program could weaken a service that people depend on. Some problems genuinely require additional resources, knowledge, or time. The findings should not be turned into a slogan urging cuts in every situation. The narrower and more accurate principle is to look for both options, then compare their effects and costs instead of letting addition win just because it was the first idea to come to mind.

What We Still Don’t Know

Much of the research conducted by the team relied on puzzles and design tasks, not long-term professional or administrative decisions. We cannot jump directly from the success of removing a LEGO brick to the conclusion that a particular institution would improve by canceling a program, or that a person would become more successful by giving up a goal. Those situations require information about expected outcomes, the people affected, and what might be lost through removal.

The results also do not say that adding is inherently less valuable than removing. Often, a new tool or resource is essential, and what seems unnecessary to one person may be vital to someone else. Broader questions remain unanswered, including how widespread this tendency is across cultures and how it develops in children as they grow. These gaps are a reason to view the study as revealing an option that can escape our attention—not as a universal formula for making decisions.

Even with these limitations, the repeated pattern across different tasks gives the idea weight: when people are asked to improve something, they may move toward addition before examining what could be done without. Making removal visible does not eliminate the need for creativity or building. It simply keeps us from limiting creativity to those two things.

The Bottom Line

Research from the University of Virginia, published in 2021, suggests that when we think about improvement, we may automatically reach for new additions—even when the simpler solution is to remove something already there. Across eight studies involving more than 1,100 people, this tendency appeared in different kinds of tasks, and participants’ choices changed when they were reminded that removal was an option. Other research on time and attention suggests that accumulating commitments and tracking multiple things at once do not necessarily help us accomplish more, though some evidence in this area remains unsettled. The practical lesson is not to always cut back. It is to give removal a clear place in our decision-making: before adding something, ask what we could stop doing, then choose based on what will actually help—not simply on which idea came first.