Skip to content

The Emergency Room Gap That Could Put Children at Risk

In Simple Terms

Not every emergency department is equally prepared to care for children. Hospitals that are better prepared have been linked to far fewer deaths among critically ill children. Improving care nationwide could cost about $200 million, and hospitals can start by building on the people and resources they already have.

A Gap You Can’t See from the Hospital Entrance

Two physicians who work in child health research and policy have pointed out that the problem of emergency care for children in the United States may be bigger than it first appears. A hospital may have an emergency department and treat children, but that alone does not show whether it has the resources and systems needed to care for them well. The concern, then, is not simply that some places lack emergency departments or emergency services. It is that the care available to children can fall short.

That gap matters because children are not just smaller versions of adults when it comes to emergency care. They need care suited to them, and the team must be ready to respond when a child’s condition changes quickly. Hospitals’ capabilities can vary depending on their location, size, and available resources. As a result, families may have very different experiences when they take a child to an emergency department.

A commentary published on October 27 drew attention to the issue. In their response, Elizabeth Sanso and Jeremy Jones added a practical perspective: alongside changes to funding, better regional coordination, and support from large hospitals for smaller facilities, each local emergency department can work to improve its own ability to respond. Broad system-wide solutions matter, but hospitals should not have to wait for every larger reform to be completed before strengthening what they can improve now.

What Does It Mean for an Emergency Department to Be Ready for Children?

Being prepared to care for children does not mean simply buying one particular piece of equipment or adding a box to a hospital checklist. It means having the people, resources, and organizational structure that help an emergency department—and emergency medical services before a patient reaches the hospital—provide high-quality care for children. That includes clear responsibility within the organization, appropriate expertise, and staff who are prepared to meet young patients’ needs.

One element Sanso and Jones highlighted is a pediatric emergency care coordinator, a role commonly abbreviated as PECC. Having a designated person responsible for monitoring the department’s readiness can help keep children’s needs in view in day-to-day work. Without someone clearly assigned to the task, responsibility can be spread so widely that no one is consistently following up. According to the response, having these coordinators is closely associated with a higher level of readiness.

That association does not mean that appointing a coordinator will solve every problem, or that other factors no longer matter. It does, however, show the value of local leadership: someone who understands the department’s strengths and gaps, can organize training and improvements, and can keep track of what the team needs. Readiness should not be treated as a short-lived campaign that ends once equipment has been purchased. It is an ongoing capability that requires attention and development.

A Number That Shows Why Readiness Is Worth the Investment

The importance of the issue is underscored by an estimate cited in the response: emergency departments with a high level of pediatric readiness were associated with a reduction of up to 76% in deaths among critically ill children. That does not mean any single improvement will reduce deaths by that amount, or that every hospital can expect the same result. But the figure points to a substantial difference between levels of readiness and suggests that the way care and resources are organized may have consequences far beyond administrative details.

The response also estimated that making every emergency department in the country ready to care for children would cost about $200 million. The authors described that amount as a small share of total annual health care spending in the United States. This comparison shifts the conversation from whether improvement is desirable to a more practical question: how can resources be distributed and directed so that appropriate care is available in more places?

The figure should be understood as a cost estimate presented in the response, not as a detailed bill for every hospital or a promise that funding alone will produce equal readiness everywhere. Putting the plan into practice would require understanding each site’s needs, identifying what is actually missing, and choosing improvements that can be sustained. Still, the estimate gives a sense of the proposed investment and makes clear that this is a national effort that can be planned for—not an open-ended demand with no defined scale.

Hospital Networks Matter, but So Does the Local Community

Broader proposals include reforming payment systems, expanding regional coordination centers, and encouraging large children’s medical centers to support smaller hospitals. Such collaboration can connect specialized expertise with facilities that do not have the same capabilities, and it can make remote support available when needed. Sanso and Jones noted that telehealth, simulation-based training, medical education, and networks for communication and mentoring among pediatric care coordinators are all being developed or used in different settings.

At the same time, the response cautions against relying only on a support system built from the top down while overlooking local knowledge. A small or rural hospital is not merely a place waiting for instructions from a larger center. Its staff and community understand local conditions and know what is difficult to access. Drawing on their work with rural and urban hospital systems and Indigenous communities, the authors stress that listening to the people affected by health services is essential to understanding what should change and how to make those changes.

That is why a single model should not be imposed on every emergency department without regard for differences in resources and needs. One facility may face obstacles that another does not, and the two may need to set different priorities. Effective collaboration brings together support from larger centers, the knowledge of local staff, and the participation of families and communities in identifying the problems that deserve attention and action.

Listening to Families Is Part of Building the Solution

The original commentary drew on stories about caring for children, and the response emphasized that accounts from families and local caregivers should remain part of the research. Numbers help measure gaps, but they cannot fully explain what a family experiences when it brings a child to the emergency department—or what prevents a local team from providing the care it wants to deliver.

The authors suggest that research should begin in partnership with community hospitals and families. Together, they can identify the questions to ask, choose appropriate ways to answer them, and think from the outset about how to share and apply the findings in a lasting way. That is different from collecting information and then leaving a community without any practical benefit from its participation. Local knowledge can help make readiness plans better suited to real conditions and more likely to continue after a particular project or training program ends.

Community involvement does not mean shifting responsibility for better care onto families or asking them to solve resource shortages. Rather, families’ voices should help set priorities and assess whether changes are truly meeting the needs of children and caregivers. Health organizations and institutions remain responsible for providing resources, supporting staff, and building systems that can be sustained.

A First Step: Assess What’s Already in Place

An emergency department can begin by assessing its current level of readiness instead of assuming that the presence of emergency services means everything children need is already available. The response encourages departments to take part in the National Pediatric Readiness Project’s national assessment, which can help identify strengths and opportunities for improvement. The point is not just to find shortcomings, but also to see what is already working and build on it.

An assessment can turn a broad goal, such as improving care for children, into specific steps that a hospital can discuss and prioritize. Once staff have a clearer picture of available resources, responsibilities, and gaps, it becomes easier to decide what to address first and which partners could help. Depending on what each site needs, support might include training, simulation exercises, mentoring between coordinators, or remote assistance.

An assessment should not be treated as a final verdict on a hospital or as a simple ranking of one institution against another. Its main value is to give staff a clearer picture of their own situation and help them set a course for improvement that fits their environment. Readiness is not a fixed state; it is an organizational capability that depends on continued review, learning, and collaboration.

The Bottom Line

Gaps in emergency care for children raise an urgent, practical question: Can every child receive appropriate care when it is needed, no matter which hospital they reach? The estimate that deaths among critically ill children may be up to 76% lower at the most prepared departments, together with a projected national cost of about $200 million, suggests that improving readiness deserves serious attention. But progress will take more than funding or broader coordination. It also depends on clear local leadership, training, partnerships, and listening to families and communities. A realistic place to begin is to assess what each department already has, strengthen its existing capabilities, and address what is missing one step at a time.