Skip to content

How Bison Helped Kansas Prairies Bounce Back—and Grow More Diverse

In Simple Terms

Over 29 years in Kansas, areas grazed by bison gained more kinds of native plants than areas grazed by cattle or left ungrazed. A severe two-year drought temporarily reduced that variety, but the bison-grazed prairie moved back toward its earlier course. The findings suggest that grazing can make room for more plants, though the study cannot separate the effects of the animal from the way it was managed.

A Prairie Became a Long-Term Experiment

The research took place at the Konza Biological Station, in the Flint Hills of eastern Kansas. The area is part of the largest remaining stretch of tallgrass prairie in the United States—land that has not been plowed to make way for farmland. That setting gave researchers the chance to follow grazing in an established grassland, rather than trying to reconstruct what the landscape looked like before farming or other major changes in land use.

The study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) on August 29, 2022. Zach Ratajczak, of the Department of Biology at Kansas State University, was the lead author. The research team also included Scott Collins, John Blair, Sarah Kuehn, Andrew Louthan, Melinda Smith, Jane Taylor, and Jesse Nippert. They drew on vegetation records collected at permanent monitoring sites over 29 years.

The researchers compared three kinds of land use: areas where no large herbivores grazed, areas grazed by bison year-round, and areas grazed by cattle only from April through November. Each experimental unit covered more than 18 hectares, giving the animals room to move and feed in ways more like those found on large working rangelands. Cattle grazed at a higher stocking density to make up for their shorter season, while the bison remained on their pasture throughout the year.

Bison returned to the station in 1987, when a herd of 30 adults was introduced. At first, the herd ranged over less than half of the area it would eventually occupy. The rest of the bison range was opened in 1992, when the herd numbered 121. Cattle were introduced to their designated area that same year, so comparisons involving the full bison range and the cattle area begin in 1992. The timing and season of cattle grazing were chosen to reflect common local practices, rather than imposing an unfamiliar system on either animal.

How Grazing Can Make Room for Other Plants

The basic idea is that dominant grasses can claim much of the available light, water, and growing space, making it harder for less common plants to thrive. The researchers’ explanation is that when large herbivores eat some of those dominant grasses, they ease the competition and give other plants a chance to take hold and grow. That does not mean grazing automatically increases plant variety everywhere: its effects depend on the animal, the grazing regime, and local conditions.

At Konza, four perennial grasses account for a large share of annual plant production: Andropogon gerardii, Sorghastrum nutans, Panicum virgatum, and Schizachyrium scoparium. When animals do not eat them, these grasses can contribute about 80% of the prairie’s annual net plant production. In areas without grazing, their cover increased slightly over time, while the number of native plant species showed no statistically significant change—whether researchers counted plants in small plots or across larger areas.

In the bison-grazed areas, cover of the four grasses initially declined, then held steady for about nine years before falling again over a period of seven years. During the final 11 years of the record, their cover fluctuated around an average of 20–25%. As the grasses became less dominant, the number of native plant species recorded in the bison areas increased.

The team measured plant diversity at two scales. One measure came from plots covering 10 square meters; the other combined data from 20 plots into a larger unit representing a small watershed. In 2020, the last year of the study, the number of native species in bison-grazed plots was 103% higher than in ungrazed land, compared with 41% in cattle-grazed areas. At the watershed scale, the difference was 86% for bison areas and 30% for cattle areas, again compared with watersheds without large herbivores.

A Long Rise Meets a Severe Drought

Native plant diversity in the bison areas generally rose from 1994 through 2010. On average, the count increased by 0.58 species per year in the small plots and by 1.06 species per year at the watershed scale. In the final year of monitoring, an individual bison-grazed plot held an average of 48.9 native plant species. Non-native plants did not become common in the grazed areas: both the bison and cattle sites averaged fewer than four non-native species per plot.

The changes involved more than a rise in the total species count. The bison-grazed plant community included species that were very rare in the other two areas, including tall flowering plants in the aster family such as Solidago rigida, as well as 11 new annual species. Two grasses, Bouteloua gracilis and Bouteloua dactyloides, also became more frequent. Both are common in the drier grasslands of the Great Plains. These observations suggest that grazing was associated with a shift in the makeup of the plant community, not merely with more names added to a species list.

The upward trend faced a major test in 2011 and 2012, the 20th and 21st years of the experiment. During the growing season in both years, the precipitation conditions index—which compares rainfall with estimates of evaporation—fell below the fifth percentile. The drought of 2012 was the most severe in the available records. The researchers described the two events as among the harshest droughts to hit the Great Plains since the Dust Bowl of the 1930s.

The number of native species in the bison areas fell during this period. It was the only part of the trend when the statistical model’s uncertainty range dropped below the level expected before the drought, indicating that plant diversity did not fully withstand the extreme conditions. But the decline did not continue indefinitely. The modeled trend moved back toward its pre-drought course after four years when researchers analyzed the small plots, and after two years at the watershed scale.

Before the drought, dominant grass cover in the cattle areas showed no clear upward or downward trend. It then dropped sharply during the drought and eventually recovered on both measures. The number of native species in the cattle areas varied from year to year between 2011 and 2020, with no net change between the start and end of that period; the uncertainty ranges for the two years overlapped. Cattle monitoring began only in 2008, so the team could not estimate a pre-drought trend for those areas comparable to the one it traced for bison.

A Striking Result, With Limits to the Comparison

The researchers compared the size of the response at Konza with a global database on how grazing affects plant diversity in grasslands. The response in the bison areas was above the 95th percentile—in other words, it ranked among the largest recorded increases in plant species richness associated with grazing. The cattle results were far below that level. The researchers argue that this makes it unlikely that features unique to the Konza site alone can explain the outcome associated with bison.

Still, the experiment cannot fully separate the effects of animal species from the effects of management. Bison grazed all year, while cattle were restricted to the growing season, from April through November, and grazed at a higher density to compensate for the shorter season. The comparison alone therefore cannot show that the difference was caused entirely by bison as a species, rather than by the duration or intensity of grazing. The team also points to a smaller study at the same site in which both species followed the same management regime; that study likewise found higher plant diversity under bison.

Using large areas made the experiment more realistic in terms of how animals move and graze unevenly across a pasture, but it also limited the number of independent experimental units. The researchers describe this as a form of incomplete replication. In their view, studying the ecosystem at a broad scale and modeling common land-use practices are valuable, even though they bring methodological challenges. A scientific commentary by Kyle Harms, published in PNAS on September 28, 2022, discussed what the bison’s stronger results could mean for restoring diversity in their grassland habitat.

What the Monitoring Period Cannot Tell Us

The study’s data end in 2020, and the drought that researchers could use to test the prairie’s response lasted two years. Research on the drought of the 1930s suggests that ungrazed grasslands in the Great Plains can withstand drought lasting four years, but that does not establish that every grassland would respond the same way, or that it could withstand even harsher conditions. The paper also noted that, by the end of the century, the likelihood of extreme droughts lasting a decade could double as a result of human-driven climate change.

The recovery observed at Konza is important evidence, but it is not a guarantee that plant diversity will withstand a longer or more severe drought. A return after two harsh years is different from a grassland’s ability to survive a full decade of low rainfall, and the study did not track what happened after 2020. Assessing how resilient grasslands are will require longer monitoring and experiments that test longer droughts, while also accounting for the ways animal species, grazing schedules, and grazing intensity interact.

The Bottom Line

Across 29 years in the Kansas prairie, bison grazing was associated with a larger increase in native plants than either cattle grazing or no grazing. By 2020, the increase over ungrazed land reached 103% in small plots and 86% at the watershed scale; the corresponding increases in cattle areas were 41% and 30%. Diversity fell during the 2011 and 2012 drought, then returned toward its earlier trend within two to four years, depending on the scale measured. The findings show how grazing can give other plants room to grow by limiting the dominance of certain grasses. But the study cannot fully separate the animal itself from how it was managed, and it does not establish whether grasslands can recover from droughts lasting many years.